A Note from the Director by Ali Tallman

 

(From left to right) David H. Hepburn, Ben Sandomir, Peter Alexander Pera, and Ryan Didato in New City Players’ production of An Enemy of the People, 2026.

When Tim and I first started discussing this play, I immersed myself in the text - Ibsen’s original, Arthur Miller’s, Amy Herzog’s, and considered my own adaptation. I’m thrilled we landed on Herzog’s version, with its streamlined language and cheeky comedic sensibility. Through them all, I found myself returning to a question familiar to Americans today: what is truth, and who gets to decide it?

Some people see this play through a black and white lens - heroes and villains, sinners and saints. That craving for clear sides has deep roots in this country’s puritanical history, and it’s a habit we’ve never quite outgrown. The uncomfortable reality is that while there is a truth that is absolute fact, there is also truth that is “the understanding that emerges through social process”; truth that requires social consensus. Democracy requires this consensus. Science advances through consensus, through tested fact supported by robust evidence and peer review.

I don’t think this is a play about some victory of an unblemished morality, but instead a play that asks whether we can stop treating truth as a singular fact or weapon long enough to build a community capable of navigating its shared problems. The play is full of legitimate but competing priorities - public health, economic survival, loyalty, reputation - and no shared way to weigh them. That doesn’t mean ignoring our priorities; it means rebuilding our capacity to navigate them together. There’s a difference between actually being right and needing to be right - or needing to be seen as right. The play is interested in what happens when the latter takes over. Individually, that need can feel justified, even righteous. But being right, without connection or productive strategy, can leave you standing alone outside a society that needs you to keep fighting from within it.

We live in an age of moral purity testing, intolerant of nuance, but real people and shared problems overflow with contradiction and conflicting priorities. Like expertise, our communities have been devalued. This play raises questions we should ask as we navigate what America looks like over the next 250 years. We have to ask: what do we lose, individually and collectively, when we insist on being right at all costs? How important is it to you to be right - is it more important than solving the problem? And what are you willing to lose for it?


AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE

By Henrik Ibsen, adapted by Amy Herzog
Directed by Ali Tallman
Nov. 13-29, 2026 at
Island City Stage

A doctor becomes convinced the town's water is making people sick. If he's right, fixing it would cost the town its livelihood. Now the whole community has to decide what comes next.

WHEN
November 13-29 2026

PRICE
$40-45

WHERE
2304 N. Dixie Hwy, Wilton Manors

Make sure to plan your visit after booking tickets!

 
New City Players